While the impending MLB lockout is going to have an obvious impact on what this winter’s arbitration process is going to look like, yesterday’s non-tender deadline provided the Guardians with their first chance to figure out what to do with their 13 arbitration-eligible players.
And the end result was their roster looking a lot like how it did when the day started, as tendered contracts to nine of their players (meaning they’re going to go to arbitration with them), signed three to contracts and non-tendered utility man David Fry.
Even if a lot can happen between now and when the season starts, that deadline would have given the Guardians’ front office a great chance to cut bait with some players on the basis of financials. Instead, they elected to keep everyone despite the fact they’re all going to have rising arbitration price tags.
We’re not out of the woods yet, but it looks like the Guardians’ brass is ready to spend at a rate we haven’t seen in years prior.
The Guardians seem set to raise their payroll in 2027
Now, to be clear, the Guardians didn’t spend a lot of money on Friday, as the only contracts they guaranteed were Matt Festa’s $1.5 million deal, Colin Holderman’s $2.175 million deal and Blake Perkins’ $950,000 deal, per The Athletic’s Zack Mesiel. But, by tendering everyone else a contract, they’re going to go through the arbitration process with every other player (so long as they don’t trade them).
One note on Blake Perkins, for all the minutiae lovers: It's technically a split contract. He earns that salary if he's in the majors. Otherwise, a much lower amount if he's in the minors. OK, now your weekend can begin.
— Zack Meisel (@ZackMeisel) November 20, 2026
That means they’re set to pay Steven Kwan $11 million and Jo Adell $10 million along with all the other smaller contracts their players are going to be owed.
Those contracts may not mean much to a franchise like the Yankees, but it’s a huge change for a Guardians franchise that’s known for making decisions with money in mind. That’s why Francisco Lindor and Josh Naylor were traded a year before arbitration, and why Shane Bieber was dealt midway through the 2025 season before he would’ve left for nothing in free agency.
While the Guardians’ decisions about Adell and Kwan are going to be the biggest litmus tests for how they want to manage their payroll, the three contracts they officially inked on Friday provide a bit of a look into how they’re planning on managing their finances.
They signed Festa for a deal right around his projected salary of $1.5 million, while both Holderman’s deal was slightly under his projected price tag. Perkins’ was more, but Meisel reported that it’s a split level deal.
The Guardians could have gone to arbitration and tried to haggle for lower contracts for all three players, but instead they guaranteed all three are going to be on their books for 2027 even though none of them are roster locks in the same way Adell and Kwan are.
A new era is officially here.
