While this year’s MLB offseason isn’t going to feature the kind of winter transaction trickle that we’re used to thanks to the impending lockout, today’s non-tender deadline is going to give us one last flurry of moves before a cold winter.
And the Guardians are going to fit into that flurry thanks to a roster filled with arbitration-eligible players who played key roles in 2026 but face uncertain futures with the franchise.
With that in mind, here are three Guardians who are at risk of being non-tendered today as the Guardians look to reshuffle their roster.
The Guardians are going to have to make some tough non-tender decisions
Matt Festa
While Feta isn’t the biggest name on the Guardians, it seems like every baseball fan in Northeast Ohio has a strong opinion about him one way or another.
Normally a middle-leverage reliever like Festa is one of the more anonymous players on a baseball team’s roster, but Festa has become a lightning rod thanks to some extreme (and puzzling) usage.
Stephen Vogt first worked with Festa in 2023 when he was the Mariners’ bullpen coach, and that affinity carried over to the 2025 season when the Guardians scooped him up off waivers. He’s appeared in 129 games with the Guardians since then while recording a 3.93 ERA.
He’s always been willing to take the ball, but it seemed clear that Vogt’s trust in Festa never really matched up with his on-field production. He's going to break the bank (projected $1.5 million salary), but now the Guardians could non-tender him and use those funds elsewhere while freeing up a spot in the bullpen.
Slade Cecconi
On Dec. 21, 2024, the Guardians acquired Cecconi from the Diamondbacks in exchange for fan favorite Josh Naylor. A little more than two years later, Cecconi’s time with the Guardians could come to an end later today.
Although he’s shown some flashes in Guardians’ rotation over the past two seasons, it was never enough to show that he should be a true rotation staple.
That said, he may still have an outside shot to be tendered a contract since he pitched well as a swingman option out of the bullpen in the postseason, though his projected $2 million salary may play a factor in that.
Cecconi should have plenty of suitors if he’s non-tendered given his age (27), big league experience and the overall lack of good starting pitching available.
Blake Perkins
Speaking of not breaking the bank, the Guardians could cut bait with Perkins despite the fact he’s projected to make just $900,000 in 2027.
Cleveland acquired Perkins in August in the deal that also netted them Craig Yoho, but he never appeared in a big league game for the Guardians in 2026. Now he’s at risk of being cut loose before ever doing so.
Perkins is never going to solve any team’s outfield problems, but he profiles as a solid fourth outfielder thanks to his above-average speed and defense. While there may have been room for Perkins on some previous iterations of the Guardians' roster, he seems like the odd man out thanks to their new outfield logjam.
