David Fry’s 2024 campaign is one of the most impressive seasons in recent Guardians history. After making his big league debut for Cleveland a year prior, Fry became an everyday player early in the ‘24 season, and ended up earning an All-Star nod thanks to a red-hot May and June.
Although his production fell off as the season went on due to an arm injury, he showed he still had one more magical swing in his bat when he launched a walk-off homer against the Yankees in the ALCS.
At the time, it looked like that season was the first big step toward him becoming an everyday player. Instead, it became the high-water mark of his time with the Guardians.
Earlier today the Guardians non-tendered Fry ahead of the 5 p.m. EDT deadline, meaning he’s now a free agent and is free to sign with any team.
David Fry's time with the Guardians came to an end at non-tender deadline
Even if Fry’s non-tender isn’t a huge surprise given he’s struggled over the past two seasons, it still stings to see him go given how much he’s meant to the Guardians during his tenure with the club.
They acquired him at the start of the 2022 season as the player to be named later in the deal that sent J.C. Mejia to the Brewers, and he made his big league debut in May 2023. He spent the rest of that season showcasing his versatility (he saw time at first, third, catcher and the corner outfield spots). That carried over to his 2024 season, and it came with a fantastic first half that made him one of the more surprising All-Stars in recent memory.
But that growth hit a speed bump when he suffered an arm injury that changed the trajectory of his career. He ended up undergoing UCL surgery after the 2024 season due to that injury, and hit just .171 in 205 while serving as a full-time designated hitter. He returned to the field in 2026 but hit just .201 as a platoon option.
When Fry was at his best he provided the Guardians with a huge boost at the field and in the batter’s box, but his injury robbed him of the ability to do both. He was still a huge clubhouse presence, but that can only go so far considering Cleveland’s offensive struggles.
While the Guardians’ front office was comfortable keeping him on their roster, he was projected to make $1.9 million via arbitration. That’s not a lot of money in the grand scheme of MLB, but now they’ll be able to use those savings elsewhere while freeing up their utility spot for someone else.
Fry’s always going to hold a special place in Guardians fandom thanks to his homer against the Yankees, but it’s going to be impossible to think about his tenure in Cleveland and not think ‘what if.’
