Guardians aggressive trade deadline has thrust them into middle of American League postseason picture

This year's trade deadline has come and gone. And what a deadline it was.

While it took until the remaining few hours for a wave of trades to finally take place, it provided us with the excitement we expected. Perhaps unexpected, but a pleasant surprise nonetheless, was the aggression of the Guardians front office to add to the Major League roster.

I lean towards the side of being anti-prospect hoarding, as I believe it is near impossible to project how a player may perform over several years and so many “top prospects” fail to live up to their projected potential.

As such, grading a return of prospects is also near impossible as every team evaluates prospects differently and while fun to debate, any outlets top prospect lists are an educated guess (at best).

For every trade where Yordan Álvarez acquired for a Josh Fields, there are probably ten Andrew Miller for Clint Fraizer/Justus Sheffield/Ben Haller/J.P. Feyereisen trades.

With that, I think the two things worth evaluating in deadline deals are whether the team should buy or sell, and, if you're a buying team, whether the player(s) brought in will provide a positive impact.

To be clear: The Guardians were smart to buy. The American League is as weak as it's been in some time and it's reasonable to think that the Guardians could go on a run if they get hot heading into the postseason. Cleveland hasn't bought in such a manner since the 2019 deadline.

Guardians aggressive trade deadline puts them right in the middle of the American League postseason picture

So what should we make of the return? 

The Guardians desperately needed a right-handed power hitter, as the heavily left-handed lineup has struggled against southpaws.

The solution was a trade for Angels outfielder Jo Adell, who now has the most home runs (16) of anyone in the Guardians' lineup.

Adell is a familiar name as a former top prospect who has found big league footing in the past couple seasons. While he's best remembered for his ridiculous game where he robbed three home runs in one game, he grades below average defensively.

In one of those fun baseball contradictions, he is a “power hitter” with an OPS+ of 92, below league average.

However, Adell mashes against lefties, so I would still evaluate the move as leaning towards positive. He has a .571 slugging percentage and .910 OPS against southpaws.

I would lean towards giving Adell the opportunity to play every day, though he grades out more as a platoon hitter. At this point, the Guardians might as well give him a shot against right-handed hitters and see if they can help him make an improvement.

The other hitter added just before the deadline was Nathaniel Lowe from the Cincinnati Reds. You may remember he was an integral part of the 2023 Texas Rangers team that won the World Series, and was a leader on that team. It can't hurt to have more leadership down the stretch.

Regardless, he's an improvement over Kyle Manzardo.

The third move made on deadline day, and my personal favorite, was the acquisition of Foster Griffin from the Washington Nationals. Yes, he is a rental, but he adds to the biggest position of strength on the team in their starting pitching and could easily get a start in a postseason series.

Aside from being a remarkable story of resilience and self-development, Griffin has been a very solid pitcher this season (3.06 ERA).

The trade also resets the rotation while moving Slade Cecconi to move to the bullpen, where manager Stephen Vogt believes he can be a versatile pitcher as both a multi-inning or one-inning reliever.

While I commend the Guardians' the front office for pushing some chips into the middle of the table, I don't think it's enough for them to make a big postseason run and catch the White Sox.

Chicago currently has a three-game lead on Cleveland, and I liked their deadline moves. Luis Castillo gives them a veteran presence in their rotation, and Brenton Doyle is a fine addition to their outfield.

The biggest thing is their front office rewarded the club with pieces to help them now despite the fact they've only been a contender for four months. I absolutely love the message to their team and fan base, and would imagine the players feel the same way.

Their offense is second in the AL in runs scored and their pitching staff is seventh in ERA. They're going to be hanging around the AL Central race all season.

The Red Sox are now favorite to win the American League, though the Rays and Yankees are both dangerous. And even if the AL West has been largely a laughing stock, the Mariners' rotation can compete with anyone’s (should they make the postseason).

Of course, I hope I'm proven wrong. Heck, Buster Olney put them at the top of his American League power rankings.

The Guardians have a great chance to make a statement this weekend with a series against the White Sox. It'll be a great chance for their new-look roster to prove themselves.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow