Guardians aggressive trade deadline could have long-term ramifications for two franchise cornerstones

Coming into this year’s trade deadline, it was clear the Cleveland Guardians needed some upgrades in their lineup. But it was anyone’s guess as to whether those upgrades would come since they’d require the Guardians to change their roster on the fly. 

And what do you know. They did it. 

After signing Jo Adell early in the day on Monday, the Guardians added another log to the deadline fire by trading for Nathaniel Lowe from the Reds at the last minute. 

It didn’t take long for the dust to clear after those trades, as the Guardians announced that roster staples David Fry and Kyle Manzardo were being sent to Triple-A in the corresponding moves. 

Roster changes indeed.

Although there was some merit to both demotions (which we’ll get to in a second), both player’s demotions make it seem like the Guardians seem comfortable altering a roster that had been largely the same since the start of 2024. 

Could that mean more change is on the horizon? Let’s dive into the moves and what they mean. 

The Guardians made two unforeseen moves by demoting Kyle Manzardo and David Fry to the minors

Let’s start with Manzardo, who the Guardians acquired as a prospect from the Rays three years ago. He made his debut midway through the 2024 season, and has recorded a .228/.306/.424 slashline with 45 home runs. 

This year has been a perfect summation of the Manzardo experience. Although he leads the Guardians with 13 home runs, which he only reached because of a hot stretch last week. 

He’s slugged just .394 this season, which is the eighth-worst mark among first baseman with 170+ at-bats (Rhys Hoskins' .333 slugging percentage is the lowest mark, FWIW). 

The Guardians evidently decided that production wasn’t enough, so they swung a trade for Lowe, who has posted an .820 OPS this season in 83 games while hitting almost exclusively against right-handed pitching. 

He’s set to be a free agent after the season, so he’s as much of a stopgap as you can get.

Lowe made his Guardians debut yesterday and went 0-for-2, while Adell went 2-for-4.

But Manzardo’s demotion also makes it fair to wonder if this is going to be it for him in Cleveland since fellow southpaw first baseman Ralphy Velazquez has been tearing it up in the minors this season and seems like the Guardians’ first baseman of the future. 

Hoskins is also a free agent, but it’s hard to believe the platoon-heavy Guardians would have two left-handed first baseman on their roster. 

But regardless of what happens with Manzardo, his demotion is another disappointing part of his up-and-down tenure with the Guardians. 

And then there’s Fry, who was hitting just .182 and hasn’t recorded a hit since July 2. It was time for him to go.

Fry holds a lot of value as a utility player, but that value is only there if he’s hitting. Otherwise he’s just a version of Jamey Carroll who can catch. And he hasn’t caught since May 26 due to Austin Hedges and Patrick Bailey’s dual offensive emergencies, so his roster spot was a bit of a waste. 

Instead it’ll be filled by Adell, who can rake against lefties (which Fry was supposed to do) while playing in the outfield. 

After the moves went through, Antonetti called the decision to demote Manzardo “a really hard decision.”  They may be faced with an even harder decision on both player’s futures after the season. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow