Skip to main content

Rising Jo Adell non-tender buzz could change conversation about Guardians’ 2026 trade deadline

ByHenry Palattella
Cleveland Guardians v Kansas City Royals
Cleveland Guardians v Kansas City Royals | Jay Biggerstaff/GettyImages

Less than three months ago, the Cleveland Guardians finally pulled the trigger and traded for Angels outfielder Jo Adell. 

Although he’d been floated as a perfect trade fit for the Guardians for the better part of three years, there never seemed to be any traction on a deal, whether it be because of Cleveland’s instance on meeting the Angels’ asking price, the insular Angels not wanting to make a deal, or some combination of both. 

It didn’t take long for the deal to look like a win for the Guardians. While Adell may have brought over some of the same warts to Cleveland that plagued him in Los Angeles, he drove in runs in bunches and provided José Ramírez and Chase DeLauter with some much-needed protection. It also came with an off-the-field benefit too given he’s still controllable through 2027 via the arbitration system. 

In theory, at least.

On Monday, the team at MLB Trade Rumors put together a huge list of potential non-tender candidates ahead of this week’s cutdown deadlines where they listed all the players they believe have a 10-20% chance of not being tendered a contract sometime between now and Friday’s deadline. 

And one of the biggest names on that list is Adell, who is projected to make $9.6 million in arbitration for 2027 (the largest amount of any player included on MLBTR’s list). 

Even if that large price tag would undoubtedly play a part in Adell potentially being non-tendered, that kind of drastic move would add a depressing footnote to the Guardians’ 2026 trade deadline. 

The Guardians are going to need to make some kind of decision about Jo Adell's 2027 contract

It would be one thing if Adell’s high arbitration price tag was the only decision the Guardians needed to make, but he’s one of 13 arbitration-eligible players on Cleveland’s roster. One of those players is Steven Kwan, who is by no means a non-tender candidate but is set to make more than $11 million in arbitration. 

And Adell has one of the weirder arbitration cases in recent memory. He finished last season with 94 RBI and has slugged 98 homers in his career, but he’s been worth just 0.9 fWAR in his career along with having a .695 OPS in 619 career games. 

Adell clearly has the skills needed to succeed in MLB, but he hasn’t put it all together despite seeing big league action in seven straight seasons. 

It would be one thing if the Guardians decided to flip Adell to another team before next month’s lockout, but giving him up for nothing as a non-tender would be one of the franchise’s biggest mistakes in recent memory. The Guardians acquired Adell from the Angels in a one to one swap involving catching prospect Jacob Cozart, and a non-tender of Adell would give the Angels a great chance to make Cleveland regret their deal for Adell. 

That trade aged well initially thanks to Adell’s run production, but that could all change this week depending on what the Guardians do with his contract. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google