The Cleveland Guardians have had a revolving door at both of their middle infield positions since Jason Kipnis and Francisco Lindor left prior to the 2020 and 2021 seasons, respectively. At times, there were top prospects being sold as the future or veteran stalwarts who served as a bridge, but nothing long-term has panned out.
This past season, Brayan Rocchio took the reins as the club’s primary shortstop, and after a few short weeks in the minors, Travis Bazzana took over as the starting second baseman. Angel Genao, naturally a second baseman, had a tad more than a cup of coffee in the big leagues this past season, playing around the diamond and tallying a handful of at-bats.
So, how should the Guardians infield shape up next year? Let’s examine each player a bit more closely.
Brayan Rocchio
Rocchio’s 2026 was a tale of two halves, as he started hot and ended ice cold. The current incumbent had a slash line of .276/.343/.408 prior to the All-Star break and then slumped to .219/.268/.367 in the second half.
But even if it was tough to watch his inconsistent, he was still steady in the field. He finished the year in the 92nd percentile in fielding run value and the 96th percentile in defensive range.
Unfortunately, “Playoff Rocchio” seemed to disappear in the postseason, as he only hit .143 in October.
In fairness to Rocchio, he had solidified himself as one of the best nine-hole hitters in baseball prior to Vogt moving him into the leadoff spot when Steven Kwan was slumping. He never re-found his groove after that.
Rocchio should still be the Guardians' shortstop on Opening Day, but his time with the club could come to an end at some point in 2027 if he doesn't turn things around.
"GOODBYE! GOOD NIGHT! UNBELIEVABLE!"
— MLB (@MLB) July 3, 2026
Brayan Rocchio launches a #walkoff 2-run homer for the @CleGuardians! pic.twitter.com/xGkRoYmbPl
Travis Bazzana
There is no doubt who the Guardians Opening Day second baseman thanks to the amount of positive steps Bazzana took in 2026.
The first thing that jumps out about Bazzana's rookie season is his keen eye at the plate that allowed for him to work counts and draw walks. Even though he hit just .245, he had an on-base percentage of .335.
It is reasonable to believe his power will develop as he develops that selectiveness within the strike zone, something that happened in his college days. Batted balls that resulted in doubles could be homers next season. Bazzana also stole 19 bases in 2026, and I expect that ti increase given the Guardians playstyle and propensity to run.
One area Bazzana will need to work on is his defense, which came to light for the wrong reasons during the postseason. Some of that was likely due to nerves (and weird hops), but there is room for improvement.
TRAVIS BAZZANA WALK-OFF HOME RUN! pic.twitter.com/wxPgF5Baqj
— MLB (@MLB) July 19, 2026
Angel Genao
Genao certainly made headlines in his MLB debut, becoming the first player in franchise history to record four hits in their debut. He was such a sparkplug in that game that Chase DeLauter dubbed him a future superstar.
This performance followed a minor league career that showed he was a natural hitter. Genao has shown a willingness to take walks and historically has not struck out as often as many other players coming through the pipeline.
Unfortunately, his bat was mostly cold the rest of the season and he only got two at-bats in the postseason. He's a contact hitter, and consistent at bats usually get the best results.
Genao did shine with the glove, however, displaying remarkable versatility as an infielder.
First plate appearance, first pitch and first hit all out of the way for Angel Genao. pic.twitter.com/anQXauHc2V
— Tim Stebbins (@tim_stebbins) August 5, 2026
I'm assuming (along with many of you) that the Guardians will have Bazzana as the starting second baseman and Rocchio as the starting shortstop on Opening Day in 2027 (whenever it is).
Bazzana was a 1:1 pick and is the future and the present. He will be given a long leash to fail and more time to find his full footing in the Majors. Rocchio is reliable defensively and that will likely earn him the job in spring camp, but I'm not sure how long he'll have it for.
I think Genao will earn a big league spot due to his bat alone and may take over as the primary utility man on the roster along with Angel Martínez. That said, I wouldn't be surprised if Genao becomes the Guardians' primary shortstop at some point in 2027.
Of note: the Guardians added Milan Tolentino to their 40-man roster on Oct. 30. If he breaks camp with the Guardians he could be a serviceable option off of the bench.
Bazzana is the obvious choice at second, but the shortstop battle could be a fun watch in spring training and the beginning of the season.
