Skip to main content

Guardians should try to capitalize on Giants' retool by trading for Casey Schmitt

ByHenry Palattella
Los Angeles Angels v San Francisco Giants
Los Angeles Angels v San Francisco Giants | Andy Kuno/San Francisco Giants/GettyImages

Over the weekend the Giants trimmed some more fat from their big league roster when they traded reliever Ryan Walker to the Brewers for two minor leaguers after previously gutting nine players from their 40-man roster at the start of the month.

While those moves helped Buster Posey and co. purge players they didn’t view as a long-term part of their future, they’re not out of the woods yet due to this week’s non-tender deadline. The Giants won’t need to make arbitration decisions on those players until after the impending lockout, but the next week will help them decide what’s next. 

And one way the Guardians could benefit from that is by trading for Giants infielder Casey Schmitt, who is one of the four arbitration-eligible players San Francisco’s front office is going to need to make a decision about. 

Although the Guardians’ need for Schmidt took a bit of a hit in the second half of the season thanks to Angel Genao’s performance as a utility player, a trade for Schmitt would help reinforce the Guardians’ middle infield while paving a way for Genao to get everyday playing time. 

Casey Schmitt would be a great fit on the Guardians' roster

It’s clear how Schmitt would help the Guardians, as he finished last season with a .784 OPS in 98 games while playing at all four infield positions along with recording 30 starts in left field. He may not get on base at the kind of rate the Guardians love (.301 on-base percentage), but that tradeoff would be worth it given his power and ability to play around the diamond. 

Last year Schmitt finished the season worth +2 Outs Above Average while grading out as an above-average fielder at every position but left field. He wouldn’t have the same kind of Gold Glove utility defense as Daniel Schneemann, but his bat would make up for it. His numbs would have been even better had he not missed the final two months of the season after sustaining a season-ending knee injury. 

The biggest thing that could complicate a potential addition of Schmitt would be his fit on the roster, but that fit would get a lot easier once you remove Brayan Rocchio from the equation. 

Although Rocchio has looked like an everyday player for the better part of the past 16 months, removing him from the picture would free up Genao to be the Guardians’ everyday shortstop while clearing up the utility role for Schmitt à la Schneemann and David Fry. 

The ace in the hole that pushes Schmitt above Schneemann or Fry is his ability to play first. Although the Guardians shouldn’t add a “pure” first baseman since they have Ralphy Velazquez waiting in the wings, Schmitt would be a good right-handed insurance option who could slot in on occasion when the Guardians don’t want to use Velazquez or fellow left-hander Kyle Manzardo. 

The Guardians have spent the past half-decade playing with some kind of utility option on their roster, and Schmitt would be the best of the bunch. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google