While the Rays have (rightly) garnered a reputation for churning through pitchers in the past half decade, one player who has stuck around in that conveyor belt is left-handed specialist Garrett Cleavinger.
He’s never been the biggest name in the Rays’ bullpen, but he’s quietly recorded 193 1/3 innings in Tampa’s bullpen since the start of 2022, which is the second-highest total among Tampa relievers in that time period behind Kevin Kelly.
But that era could come to an end this week thanks to this week’s roster deadlines, as the team at MLB Trade Rumors recently put together a list of potential non-tender candidates where Cleavinger was front and center on the list in the group of left-handed relievers.
That doesn’t mean that Cleavinger is guaranteed to get non-tendered, especially since the Rays tend to think outside the box more than any other team in baseball. But it does make it seem like there’s a legitimate shot that Cleavinger could be cut loose — which should be music to the Guardians’ ears.
Garret Cleavinger would be a clear Guardians’ free agent target should the Rays non-tender him
The potential value Cleavinger would provide is simple: he gets righties out. Although it may seem like Cleavinger would be a lefty specialist given he’s a southpaw himself, Cleavinger has held right-handed batters to a .203 batting average in his career. The biggest reason he’s been able to do that is thanks to a wipeout slider and dominant fastball. He was able to hold right-handed hitters to a .213 average last season on those two pitches.
While that pitch pairing worked, it was a different story for left-handed hitters, as they lit him up to the tune of an .832 OPS. But we don’t have to look too far to see how that kind of pitching profile has helped Cleaviger find success before.
In 2025, the 32-year-old finished the season with a sparkling 2.35 ERA in 61 1/3 innings while serving as a quality setup man. The Rays may not have made the postseason in 2025, but Cleavinger’s performance was good enough for him to earn a spot on Team USA in the World Baseball Classic, where he pitched one scoreless inning.
Although none of Cleavinger’s other seasons with the Rays reached those heights, he still entered 2026 with a 2.96 ERA in 152 innings with Tampa Bay. But that may not be enough to save him from the Rays’ roster crunch, partly because of his struggles in 2026 and partly because of his projected $3.7 million contract.
That price tag may be too rich for the Rays, but it would be right in the Guardians’ wheelhouse, especially since Chris Antonetti said the Guardians are looking to spend more in 2027.
Cleavinger would be a welcome addition to the Guardians’ middle-leverage picture as an option ahead of Hunter Gaddis and Cade Smith. He and Erik Sabrowski may seem redundant next to each other in that role since they’re both lefties, but Cleavinger’s reverse splits mean they’d be a great fit next to each other.
Teams don’t usually get a chance to pull one over on the Rays, but the Guardians could change that should the Rays choose to let Cleavinger go.
