Indians shouldn’t have DFA’d Jerry Sands
In today’s edition of Hey, Hoynsie!–Paul Hoynes was asked about the indecisiveness of theCleveland Indians
with Jerry Sands, as well as what to do with the strugglingNick Swisher
. You can read more about it
But we’ll cover the Sands/Swisher question, as I have to disagree wit Hoynes on this.
First off, Sands cleared waivers after being designated for assignment for the second time this season. For as well as he’s hit in his time with the Indians this season (9-for-27, one home run and two doubles), no team has claimed him either time. So what the Tribe see in him might be right if no one else is willing to take a chance.
My problem is his simple explanation. Hoynes says “there’s a reason he’s not in the big league’s right now, just as there was a reason the Indians signed Swisher to a four-year, $56 million contract.”
Ok, so what’s the reason? Poor performance? No. Everyone at his position is playing better? No, that’s not it. And the reason the Tribe paid Swisher that money? Well, whatever it is, they overpaid. Not unusual in free agency, but handing a guy $14 million a year at his age was a terrible idea. Let’s not fall back on that and play it as ‘Swisher is better than Sands’. That’s simply not true right now.
More from Away Back Gone
- Cleveland Guardians tantalizingly close to locking up AL Central tiebreakers
- Cleveland Guardians: Terry Francona becomes meme in profanity-laced ejection
- Say goodbye to defensive shifts and hello to bigger bases, pitch clock in 2023
- Cleveland Guardians: Shane Bieber second-fastest to 800 strikeouts in major-league history
- The next week will make or break the Cleveland Guardians’ season
Granted, Swisher and his money aren’t going anywhere. And coming off double knee surgery with the numbers he’s putting up? No one will take him in trade without the Indians eating most of the contract. And his knees seem a better fit for first base, but Tito isn’t going to sit Carlos Santana–so here we are. And Sands is only 27, so he’s by no means washed up. He could be hitting his stride for all we know.
The Indians were lucky with Shaun Marcum after waffling with him, and so far he has fallen in line as the best No. 5 starter option that they have at this point. Now that they’ve had the same stroke of luck with Sands, maybe in the near future they’ll reconsider Sands future. Playing Swisher strictly because of his contract is poisonous. I watched it for years with the Chicago Cubs and Alfonso Soriano. You found yourself trying to justify it. He wasn’t terrible. Far better than Swish right now.