Last week we got our first rumors around the Guardians when MLB Insider Jon Heyman reported the Guardians were among the teams interested in free agent reliever Tim Hill. Hill may not be the biggest name in free agency, but that connection seemed like the first step toward what could be a fruitful offseason.
And while that could still be the case, it’s not going to be an offseason that’s going to include Hill, as he returned to New York over the weekend on a one-year, $2.25 million deal that includes a $2.5 million club option for next season.
While Hill being taken off the board doesn’t mean the Guardians’ offseason is over (far from it), it does show that the Guardians are going to need to pay a bit more than they’d like to be able to add to their bullpen.
Tim Hill is a Yankee once again
The 36-year-old Hill is coming off his third season with the Yankees, where he’s posted a 3.34 ERA in 169 2/3 innings. His best season in Pinstripes came in the second half of the 2024 season after they first acquired him in 2024, as he had a 2.05 ERA in 44 innings while also being a shutdown reliever for them in the postseason.
Hill struggled last season, though he still finished the season in the top percentile in ground ball rate and walk rate, which are the kind of traits that helped him earn another big league contract with the Yankees (while also getting attention from the Guardians).
The one big reason why the Yankees targeted Hill is the fact they lost two other star relievers to free agency (David Bednar or Paul Blackburn) and could lose them to another team.
Although Hill’s contract clearly doesn’t break the bank (especially for the Yankees), it does provide us an interesting thought exercise about what ended up becoming a bridge too far for the Guardians.
Was the club option too much? Or maybe the contract exceeding the $2 million threshold? Was Hill always destined to head back to the Yankees?
We’re not going to know the answer to those questions until the spring training (if ever), but we don’t usually hear a ton about the Guardians having interest in players unless there’s some legitimate smoke to that fire.
But now we know that Hill isn’t going to be a Guardian, which means that they’re still going to be scouring the free agent market to try and gain another relief arm. Maybe a deal with Blackburn could be in the cards since it would remove a key piece from the Yankees’ bullpen, or maybe they go after a solid left-handed option like JoJo Romero.
But whoever they add, it’s not going to be Hill.
