Every MLB offseason gives us a shocking trade or two at some point during the winter. This year’s version of that deal came before Northeast Ohio’s first snowfall.
On Wednesday, the Kansas City Royals traded third baseman Maikel Garcia and pitcher James McArtuhur to the Mariners in exchange for a three-pitcher return highlighted by starting pitcher Bryce Miller.
Full trade, per ESPN sources.
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) November 18, 2026
Mariners receive: 3B Maikel Garcia, right-handed reliever James McArthur and a minor league reliever
Royals receive: right-handed starter Bryce Miller, left-handed reliever Jose Ferrer, right-handed starter Logan Evans
After not making it to the postseason in 2025 and ‘26, the Royals decided to cash in on one of their most tradable assets to help reinforce a rotation that’s been one of their biggest issues in recent years.
While Kansas City’s rotation is still going to struggle to reach the same kind of heights as the Guardians’, their trade for Miller showed they’re willing to take a big swing to try to finally dethrone the Guardians.
The Royals' fortified their rotation by trading for Bryce Miller
This deal is the rare one that looks great for both sides, as the Mariners appear to have solved their infield issues while the Royals added two bonafide MLB pitchers to their roster picture in Miller and reliever Jose Ferrer.
Although Garcia only managed to make it into 82 games last year due to some injury issues, he’s just one season removed from an All-Star 2025 campaign where he had an .800 OPS while also winning a Gold Glove. He signed a team-friendly five-year, $57.5 million campaign on the back of that season, which made him an easy fit for a Mariners team that already has Julio Rodríguez and Josh Naylor’s extensions on its books.
But the biggest way this trade is going to impact the Guardians is Kansas City’s addition of Miller, who showed flashes of being an ace in 2024 before injuries derailed in 2025 and ‘26 seasons.
He only managed to throw 90 1/3 innings in 2025 due to some elbow inflammation, and he started last season on the injured list with an oblique injury. The Mariners had already declined his $6 club option for 2027, which sent him back into the arbitration process.
Almost every other team in MLB would be fine riding the Miller wave since he still has three years of team control remaining, but the Mariners were looking to trim at least one pitcher from their rotation, and decided Miller was going to be the odd man out.
Ferrer could also see some time as the Royals’ closer after getting some high-leverage work in his first (and only) season in Seattle.
This deal also seems to take Logan Gilbert off the trade market, which removes them as a potential Steven Kwan trade partner. It’s hard to believe the Guardians would have swapped Kwan’s impending free agency for Gilbert’s, but Miller being traded means any deal between the two is going to stay as a hypothetical.
The Royals haven’t been much of a factor for the Guardians in the past couple seasons, but that may not be the case in 2027.
