Why David Fry could be key in helping Guardians unlock new-look lineup 

At face value, David Fry’s performance this season has been a bit underwhelming since he’s only had 36 at-bats (one more than Austin Hedges) and has only driven in one run on a solo home run. 

But the value that Fry provides to the Guardians is so much more than just what he provides at the plate thanks to his defensive versatility, which we could be seeing more of as the Guardians shift into a world where Travis Bazzana is on their big league roster. 

The biggest way where Fry helps the Guardians is his ability to play in the field and catch, which opens up a new world for Stephen Vogt when it comes to lineup construction and late-game maneuvering. 

Last year Fry was arguably the least-versatile player on the Guardians’ roster since he was a full-time designated hitter due to the Tommy John surgery he underwent the season prior. But he’s one of the most important, as he’s seen time at catcher, first base and right field this season (he can also play third in a pinch, if needed). 

The Guardians’ roster was already one of baseball’s most versatile thanks to Daniel Schnemann, but a healthy Fry takes it to another level. 

Not only can Vogt pinch-hit for Bo Naylor late in a game against a left-handed pitcher (which he’s already done twice this year), but he can do so without needing to worry about burning his backup catcher. 

It’s a win-win.

David Fry’s unique skillset is a huge advantage for the Guardians 

He also provides the Guardians with some much-needed right-handed thump, which is even more important now since Cleveland added Bazzana to the roster at the cost of the switch-hitting Juan Brito. 

Not that Brito was hitting anything much of anything during his time with the Guardians, but adding Bazzana removes a bit of balance to the lineup. 

That’s great when the Guardians are facing a right-handed pitcher (like they did in their final two games against the Rays), but they’re going to need some kind of right-handed presence in their lineup against southpaws. 

Not only does Fry provide that, but he does so in a way where he can move all around the diamond. He could spell Naylor or Hedges behind the plate, Kyle Manzardo at first or one of the corner outfield options. 

Now, all of that is to say that the Guardians are still going to need something from Fry at the plate. While it seems like it would be foolish to expect him to replicate his performance from the first half of 2024 when he hit everything in sight en route to an All-Star nod, some kind of offensive production would still be nice. 

The good news is that he’s posted one of the best walk rates in baseball (18.2%), which helps make up for his lack of hard contact. 

Fry may not be the biggest name on the Guardians’ roster, but he’s quickly becoming one of the most important. That’s not going to change any time soon. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow