Earlier this offseason White Sox general manager Chris Getz went on the record and said the White Sox are going to prioritize their starting rotation this winter (when the transaction window isn’t frozen).
On Tuesday Getz put his money where his mouth is by signing free agent starting pitcher Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million contract to be the new ace of Chicago’s rotation. While that contract would be an overpay no matter, it seems like even more of an overpay given the White Sox are less than four months removed from acquiring Luis Castillo and his expensive contract at the deadline to do the exact same thing.
BREAKING: Free-agent pitcher Dustin May and the Chicago White Sox are in agreement on a three-year contract worth just north of $50 million, according to sources familiar with the deal.
— Robert Murray (@ByRobertMurray) November 17, 2026
May’s a better option than Castillo, but he’s an expensive one, especially when you consider it looked like there was a chance the Guardians could go after him.
The Guardians obviously need some rotation help, but it’s hard to imagine their stingy front office would be comfortable paying May a contract with an AAV north of $17 million.
And even if they were, it’s hard to imagine that contract aging well given the amount of wear and tear on his arms. May made sense as a trade target for the Guardians at a low-cost short-term contract, and the White Sox made the bold decision to sign him for a contract that’s the exact opposite of that.
The White Sox overpaid for Dustin May
May finished last season with a 4.70 ERA in 145 2/3 innings across his stints with the Cardinals and Brewers, though most of his positive production came in St. Louis. He had a 4.38 ERA with the Cardinals that included the first shutout of his career before it ballooned to 5.65 with the Brewers. He also struggled in the postseason.
But he’s still been an analytics darling thanks to his power arsenal and solid under-the-hood numbers, but it’s still a bit jarring to see him sign such a large contract considering he posted 4.82 ERA in 278 innings across the 2025 and ‘26 seasons.
But the White Sox aren’t in a position to be picky. Their trade for Castillo has been an incredibly expensive midfire, and they don’t have much depth behind ace Sean Burke. They’re moving Grant Taylor to the rotation after a solid postseason showing out of the bullpen, but that was pretty much it.
May is now the leader of that unit, but it’s going to take a lot for his contract to age well. May suffered his first serious arm injury in 2021 when he underwent Tommy John surgery, and he only pitched in 48 innings the next season. He missed all of 2024 due to a variety of injuries, and he’s been able to stay healthy since (with varied results).
The White Sox rotation may be better with May in it, but it may not be that way for long.
