Who is in the Cleveland All-Time WAR lineup?

Cleveland Guardians v Minnesota Twins
Cleveland Guardians v Minnesota Twins / David Berding/GettyImages
5 of 7

Catcher: Steve O'Neil 24.7 WAR

While not the highest total of anyone who played catcher in Clevleand, Steve O'Neill played catcher nearly exclusively (one game at first) which is why he gets the nod over Carlos Santana here. O'Neill spent 13 years as Cleveland's backstop from 1911 until 1923. A .311/.423/.416 slash line in 1922 saw a 30-year old O'Neill finish sixth in MVP voting.