Dud: Hunter Gaddis
If there is anything that was learned about Hunter Gaddis is that he does not belong in the Guardians rotation. Gaddis allowed 14 runs in 19.2 innings and has been very hittable with 22 hits allowed in his five appearances.
The only positive takeaway from Gaddis' early season appearances is that it forced the Guardians to turn to other more promising arms in Logan Allen and Tanner Bibee. Gaddis will more than likely make another apperance for the Guardians this season, hopefully that it will not be the role as a long-term starter.