Guardians would be wise to seek reunion with Carlos Santana if Josh Naylor is dealt

There has been plenty of speculation about the Cleveland Guardians' plans for first base next season. The possibility of going down a very familiar road by trading an impending free agent in Josh Naylor seems quite likely. While the pros and cons of that decision will undoubtedly be weighted heavily if they do indeed take that route, there is a familiar face who would be a perfect short-term solution: Carlos Santana.

A few days ago, it was reported that Santana is looking to play an additional three to four more seasons. The 38-year-old veteran won his first career Gold Glove at first base this past season and would be a positive defensive presence in Cleveland's infield while the organization eases Kyle Manzardo into being their future at the position. Even though some may argue in favor of just handing it off to Manzardo and moving forward, having an experienced option in the mix will also give Cleveland a much-needed larger margin for error.

There is also something else at play here. With David Fry undergoing surgery that will keep him from taking the field defensively in 2025, a trade of Naylor would require the Guardians to have an additional individual capable of playing first base in the event Manzardo does not take the step forward the organization anticipates or goes down with an injury. Having a more than adequate alternative is a bare minimum requirement that would have catastrophic consequences if not met. A reunion with Santana would definitely help them avoid a disastrous scenario that could derail their season in an instant should either scenario with Manzard comes to fruition.

Is there some risk with signing someone who will turn 39 very early in the season? Sure, but it must be mentioned that Santana is still a productive bat, and inserting his skill set into Cleveland's lineup as currently constructed would be highly beneficial if they do indeed trade Naylor this offseason, as it would help prevent any sort of offensive drop-off and put the Guardians in position to remain atop the American League Central division in 2025.