Last month, the entire MLB world got a first-hand look at some of the Guardians’ previous mistakes when Jake Bauers and Junior Caminero faced off in the World Series.
Tonight provided a bit more salt in that wound, as both Caminero and Bauers were named Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger award winners. Caminero won it at third base in the American League, while Bauers won it in the utility category in the National League. The winners were officially unveiled on FanSided's The Baseball Insiders podcast, co-hosted by Adam Weinrib and FanSided MLB insider Robert Murray.
Although the Guardians netted a win of their own via Chase DeLauter winning his first career Silver Slugger, some of that shine was taken away due to the fact that his name will forever be etched next two former Guardians who also took home awards.
Jake Bauers and Junior Caminero both netted Silver Slugger wins for their 2026 season
Bauers and Caminero had two very different paths to becoming Silver Sluggers after their stints in Cleveland ended. The Guardians initially acquired Bauers in a trade prior to the 2019 season, and he bounced around MLB after leaving Cleveland before latching on with the Brewers (he’s since signed a contract with the Red Sox).
Meanwhile, the Guardians traded Caminero when he was an 18-year-old third base prospect who had just finished up a season in the Dominican Summer League. He went on to become the No. 1 prospect in baseball, and has blossomed into one of the sport’s best sluggers.
Although Caminero’s departure stings much more than Bauers’ since he immediately hit his peak, Bauers’ win still creates a ton of ‘what ifs,’ especially given his postseason heroics.
JAKE BAUERS PUTS THE BREWERS BACK IN FRONT! pic.twitter.com/KK8xCFd7j1
— MLB (@MLB) October 15, 2026
Bauers posted an .874 OPS with 26 homers and 86 RBI in the regular season (far and away the best numbers of his career) before going nuclear in the National League Championship Series. Caminero, on the other hand, finished the year with his second straight 40+ homer, 100+ RBI season before going quiet in the postseason (though he did record a signature moment against the Guardians).
JUNIOR CAMINERO
— MLB (@MLB) October 20, 2026
OFF THE FOUL POLE
THE TROP IS ELECTRIC! pic.twitter.com/E0hC0eAmBK
José Ramírez held off Caminero in last year’s race for the American League’s Silver Slugger at third base, but his struggles opened the door for Caminero this time around, who barged right through it. This year’s award could be a tangible changing of the guard in the American League at third base.
Bauers is going to enter the American League Silver Slugger fray in 2027 next year thanks to that aforementioned contract with the Red Sox. Although he should see plenty of time at first for them next year, he may end up being a utility nominee again next year due to how much he may move around the diamond.
