Skip to main content

Guardians have solid opportunity to fortify pitching depth via Nationals pitching scraps 

ByHenry Palattella
New York Mets v. Washington Nationals
New York Mets v. Washington Nationals | Alyssa McDaniel/GettyImages

More than six years ago, the Los Angeles Dodgers acquired Max Scherzer from the Nationals for a four-player return highlighted by catcher Keibert Ruiz and Josiah Gray. 

While Ruiz has blossomed into a bonafide starting catcher who seems to be a big part of the Nationals’ bright future, Gray’s time with the franchise officially came to an end earlier this week when Washington designated him for assignment ahead of the deadline to protect players from the Rule 5 Draft. 

It’s a bit of an unceremonious end for Gray, who ended up blossoming into an All-Star with the Nationals but has had the past three seasons derailed due to injuries. He made his return to the big league mound earlier this season, but that wasn’t enough to save him from losing his spot as a part of Washington’s roster cut down. But the Nationals’ loss could end up becoming the Guardians’ gain thanks to Gray becoming a free agent. 

Josiah Gray could help reinforce the Guardians’ pitching depth 

Gray’s best season with Washington came in 2023 when he tallied a 3.59 ERA in 159 innings and looked like a blossoming ace.

The Nationals had already won their trade by then thanks to Scherzer and Turner spurning Los Angeles for other cities, but Gray looked like he was going to turn it into a trade that Dodgers fans would come to rue forever. 

But then Gray was placed on the injured list after just two starts in 2024 with an arm injury that led to him undergoing surgery to repair a tear in his UCL. He missed all of the 2025 season with the injury and didn’t make his return until the end of 2026 due to various rehab issues. 

He may never reach the previous heights he hit during 2023, but it looked like he had shown enough at the end of the season to earn a roster spot for 2027. But that wasn’t the case, partly because the Nationals current brain trust inherited him. 

But their lack of interest in him could be the Guardians’ gain. Cleveland’s no stranger to buying low on injured or underperforming pitchers, and Gray’s the poster child for both those categories. 

While he only recorded 16 innings last year in the minors and big leagues, his slider and curveball both showed some bite in that brief outing. 

He shouldn’t be the only pitching reinforcement the Guardians go after, but he’s a solid depth option who could benefit from some under the hood tinkering from the Guardians’ pitching lab. While it would be foolish to imagine they could turn him into an All-Star again, the Guardians’ have done more with less in the past. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google