Skip to main content

Guardians could cash in on reliever depth thanks to Brewers wild Ryan Walker trade 

ByHenry Palattella
May 9, 2026: San Francisco Giants pitcher Ryan Walker (74) walks to the dugout after a pitching change against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the sixth inning at Oracle Park. Credit: Robert Edwards-Imagn Images
May 9, 2026: San Francisco Giants pitcher Ryan Walker (74) walks to the dugout after a pitching change against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the sixth inning at Oracle Park. Credit: Robert Edwards-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

In 2024, Ryan Walker quietly rose through the San Francisco bullpen’s trust tree to take over the team’s closer role from former All-Star Camilo Doval. Although Walker spent most of the 2023 season pitching in the big league for the Giants, he became a household name in 24 thanks to a 1.91 ERA in 80 innings with 10 saves. It made it seem like he was going to be the Giants’ closer of the future. 

That never became the case, and now he’s not a part of the Giants’ bullpen of the present. On Sunday, the Giants traded Walker to the Milwaukee Brewers in exchange for pitching prospects Blake Holub and Gavin Perry. That kind of deal may have seemed like a head scratcher two years ago given Walker’s rising star, but it’s still a head scratcher now given Walker’s coming off a season where he had a 7.16 ERA in 32 2/3 innings.

There’s going to be a lot of ink spilled about how the Brewers could morph Walker back into a legitimate closer again, but another thread to pull from this trade is the fact the Giants were able to get two prospects in exchange for a pitcher who was (and still is) a non-tender candidate. 

Teams are always on the hunt for bullpen options, and the Guardians are in the unique place of seemingly always having pitching depth thanks to their pitching pipeline. That’s not to say the Guardians should trade one of their bullpen arms, but the Brewers’ trade shows the Guardians could cash in on that depth, should they choose. 

The Ryan Walker trade gives the Guardians a great chance to capitalize on their bullpen depth

The biggest arm the Guardians have in their bullpen who makes sense as a trade target is setup man Hunter Gaddis, who has posted a 2.50 ERA in 212 1/3 innings since moving to the bullpen in 2023. He may be prone for the occasional blowup, but he’s a steady presence who could be a closer for most teams that don’t have Cade Smith. 

But it’s not like they just need to float Gaddis to cash in on the bullpen market. The Brewers getting two prospects for Walker makes it seem like Tim Herrin, Colin Holderman or even Logan Allen could net the Guardians a solid return should they choose to trade any of them.

Of that group, Herrin would likely get the most return since he has a ton of big league experience. He may have command issues, but his career 3.41 ERA laps Walker’s recent results. 

Trading Herrin (or any of the above arms) would hurt the Guardians’ big league bullpen, but they have some ready-made replacements in Franco Aleman, Craig Yoho and Daniel Espino (should they choose to keep him in the bullpen). 

The MLB offseason always throws us some curveballs, but the Guardians now have a chance to use the latest curveball to their advantage.

Add us as a preferred source on Google