Assessing the state of the Guardians' rotation one month into 2026 season

When the weather started to turn and spring training began, the storylines around the Guardians' rotation were pretty clear.

Tanner Bibee and Gavin Williams would be the 1-2 punch at the top, while Slade Cecconi, Parker Messick, Joey Cantillo, and Logan Allen would battle for the final three spots.

When the regular season began it was clear that the majority opinions ended up being the correct one. Bibee got the Opening Day nod followed by Williams, while Allen ended up being the odd man out.

For most teams, the ace at the top of the rotation is the most important pitcher on the staff and the back of the rotation exists just to eat some inning.

For the Guardians, however, it seems like the back of the rotation could be more important than the front. Here's how things look with Cleveland's pitching staff through the first month of the season.

The Guardians' rotation is still a bit in flux

Tanner Bibee and Gavin Williams

The top of the Guardians' rotation has been solid but not spectacular. While neither of them have had a bad outing (outside of Bibee's blowup start against the Braves), most of their starts haven't been excellent.

A big reason for their lack of high-end outings has been command and high pitch counts that limit their ability to go deep. That leads to to extra bullpen usage and the back of the rotation needing to eat more innings.

Parker Messick 

What is there to be said that hasn't been said already?

There's no denying it: Messick feels like the next man to blossom in the Guardians' pitching factory. He's record a 1.76 ERA through his first six starts, and has limited the oppositing to one run or less in three of those starts.

He also almost threw his way into the Guardians' record books by throwing eight no-hit innings against the Baltimore Orioles.

If Messick is able to keep this up, he'll become one of the best pitchers in baseball (along with being the lynchpin of the Guardians' rotation).

His stellar command and lack of strikeouts mean that he should be able to go at least six innings in most of his starts even if things aren't going right.

Joey Cantillo

Cantillo has been the classic No. 5 starter through the first month of the season in that he's going 5ish innings in every start while giving up a couple of runs.

There's still a chance that there's a bit more juice in his arm, but there are still worse options for a back-end starter if this remains the status quo.

The biggest thing Cantillo can do to reach is another level is by being a bit more consistent since he has a history of getting pulled after innings slip away from him.

Slade Cecconi 

Cecconi is the only pitcher Guardians pitcher who has run into serious struggles through the first month of the season.

He's had one good start through the first month compared to four bad ones — three of which were very bad.

In that one good start, he went six scoreless innings against the Cubs and showed exactly why he has the potential to be so good. But it's been rough aside from that.

While he only gave up one run in his start against the Cardinals, that was largely because he only went four innings and surrendered five walks.

He's allowed at least five runs in his other three starts and has put manager Stephen Vogt in a postion where the Guardians need to try to squeeze as much out of his possible so that way their bullpen doesn't get too taxed.

The overall returns of the rotation have been solid. Williams has shown flashes of true ace potential, Bibee has fought through trouble and Messick looks like a difference maker.

However, the pitchers who will have the biggest impact on where this team goes could be Cantillo, Cecconi, and potentially Allen if he gets called up. If those guys can consistently give the team six solid innings, it will take a lot of pressure off Bibee and Williams, which will help everyone on the roster.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow