Skip to main content

Aging Guardians legend attempting to eek one more season out of big league career

ByHenry Palattella
Detroit Tigers v Arizona Diamondbacks
Detroit Tigers v Arizona Diamondbacks | Christian Petersen/GettyImages

It looked like last season was going to be the final time we saw Carlos Sanatana on a big league diamond. 

After signing a one-year, $2 million with the Arizona Diamondbacks to be a veteran leader, he went 2-for-24 in the desert before suffering a right adductor strain that put him on the injured list. The Diamondbacks ended up designating him for assignment, and he finished the season in the Diamondbacks minor league system waiting for a big league opportunity that never came. 

That uneventful end to the 2026 season meant the 40-year-old recorded a .614 OPS in 132 games with the Guardians, Cubs and Diamondbacks across the 2025 and ‘26 seasons. It looked like he was out of gas and ready to sail off into the sunset. 

While the first part of that statement may be true, the second part doesn’t seem to be true, as The Athletic’s Will Sammon, Ken Rosenthal and Katie Woo reported over the weekend that Santana wants to keep playing and is looking to sign a contract with a team for 2027. 

We’re not sure why Santana wants to keep doing this, but we do know that the Guardians need to stay far away. 

Carlos Santana is trying to keep his big league career going

The Guardians already made one mistake around late-career Santana when they signed him to a one-year, $12 million contract for 2025 on the same day they traded Josh Naylor to the Diamondbacks. 

Santana provided the Guardians with his customary solid defense, but he had a .650 OPS in 113 games with a .333 slugging percentage. They cut him loose at the end of August, but the Cubs claimed him off waivers so he could be a veteran presence on their bench. 

The Diamondbacks brought him in so he could fill that same role, but his struggles and injuries made it impossible for them to keep him on their roster. He then signed that aforementioned deal with the Braves and posted a .767 OPS in 27 games at Triple-A, but he always had an uphill battle to make their big league roster since Atlanta first baseman Matt Olson has played in 944 straight games, and was eventually cut loose from that deal at the end of August. 

Santana’s currently playing in the Dominican Winter League in his attempt to author another big league comeback, but he’s gone 0-for-7 with a walk in two games so far. 

Santana should be able to sign some kind of minor league deal with a team since there’s no risk to bringing him in, but it’s hard to believe that’ll happen before the lockout given the time crunch teams will be dealing with to shore up their big league rosters. Instead, Santana will probably linger in free agency throughout the lockout and then be brought in as a depth option once transactions can happen again. 

The end of Santana’s career won’t take away from the heights he reached during his peak with Cleveland, but it’s time for the Guardians to stay far away. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google