The 2024 season was a productive one for the Cleveland Guardians. Expectations across the board were not high, with most projections having the Guardians being an afterthought at best. Not only were the Guardians able to surpass the expectations of most, but they were able to make it all the way to the American League Championship Series. Their success has altered how the organization has to operate heading into this offseason, making the following internal conversations they were going to need to have a bit more difficult.