Cleveland Indians: The 2022 starting rotation is already set and it’s promising

The 2022 starting rotation is already set for the Cleveland Indians / Cleveland Guardians and it’s looking promising.

The Cleveland Indians have struggled during the 2021 season in a way that we really haven’t witnessed since 2012. The team is on the brink of finishing below .500 for the first time during the Terry Francona era and a large part of the team’s hardships boils down to the starting pitching.

Over the last couple seasons the Tribe has essentially traded away an entire starting rotation, dealing Corey Kluber, Trevor Bauer, Mike Clevinger and Carlos Carrasco who served as the core of the team for the last few years. With the goal to save money and build for the future obvious, these came with little shock, however, it left the team in an interesting place.

The emergence of Shane Bieber originally completed the rotation in Cleveland, but injuries to others opened the door for fellow 2016 MLB Draftees Aaron Civale and Zach Plesac. With both Civale and Plesac showing signs of growth, the opportunity to make a big change in the rotation was present. The only problem was that two spots were still uncertain and injuries killed the club this year.

With questionable starting pitching in the backend of the rotation at the beginning of the year, Cleveland was already using Bieber, Civale and Plesac at high rates. Each outing was expected to nearly go the distance to save the bullpen for the other two starters. Then, the injuries started piling up and it was the beginning of the end to Cleveland’s season.

With a starting rotation that not even Lou Brown could coach or be proud of, Cleveland’s season seemed destined to be deadline sellers to cut more payroll and prepare for the future. And that’s exactly what happened. The young rotation couldn’t keep up and the season slowly died. However, there is a positive out of all of this.

Given the length of opportunities for the pitchers that were called on to fill out the rotation, Cleveland has a rather clear answer to what the starting rotation will look like in 2022. In fact, there might have to be a competition to fill the final spot, but in a good way as multiple pitchers are showing potential. It isn’t like this year where the team is searching for an arm, but instead they will be deciding which one is better.

So while this season hurt to watch when it came to starting pitching, it might be all for the better because it’s setting the stage for the next great Cleveland rotation at the start of the 2022 season.

Aaron Civale, SP, Cleveland Indians

Right next to Bieber on the injured list is Aaron Civale. Like Bieber, Civale was looking strong early in the season and was even talked about as being on the same level as the defending Cy Young winner. He was the first pitcher in the game to hit double-digit wins in 2021, but unfortunately an injury hasn’t allowed him to get even win 11 yet.

Civale is a bit ahead of Bieber in the recovery process, having thrown a simulated game, so the odds of getting Civale back this season is a bit higher. At the time of his injury he was putting up some of the better numbers of his career, so it will be interesting to see if he can get back to that form before the 2021 season closes out.

Even if he can’t get all the way there, Civale is poised to be one of the better starters in Cleveland next year. He showed promise this season after a bit of a more difficult 2020 season. Having the offseason to get fully healthy and then Spring Training to relocate what was working earlier this season should set up Civale to be one of the better pitchers not only in Cleveland in 2022, but possibly in the entire American League.

Zach Plesac, SP, Cleveland Indians

It seems like every time Zach Plesac appears to be turning the corner on the mound to get to the next level of his potential something non-baseball related happens. Whether it be partying during COVID or aggressively removing his shirt, Plesac’s issues away from the mound have been what has kept him from tapping into his full potential.

Like Bieber and Civale, Plesac had an injury this year, thanks to a rogue chair that got in the way of his thumb in the locker room. However, Plesac has been the only one of the “Big Three” to return already this season. Unfortunately, the results haven’t been what was hoped for.

After missing all of June, Plesac has made seven starts between July and August. He has managed to allow at least two runs in every single one of those seven starts. Over that time he’s posted an ERA of 5.40. Over 38.1 innings he’s managed to strikeout just 29 batters while walking seven and giving up 10 doubles and nine home runs.

That’s not promising, but the good news is that might be the most concerning thing for the starting rotation going into next year. Plesac’s shown his potential, posting a 2.28 ERA in 2020, but consistency just hasn’t been there.

An offseason to get fully healthy and a Spring Training to find his groove again should hopefully get Plesac back on track. Plus, not being the far-and-away best pitcher of the rotation should relieve some pressure as well.

Cal Quantrill, SP, Cleveland Indians

The rise of Cal Quantrill this season has been well documented and now a solid start for him isn’t even newsworthy, but expected. Arriving as part of the Mike Clevinger trade a year ago, Quantrill has made nearly a seamless transition from the bullpen to the starting rotation this season and has positioned himself to be locked in for a back-end rotation spot in 2022.

Another member of the 2016 MLB Draft class, Quantrill was actually the highest drafted of Cleveland’s rotation, albeit by the San Diego Padres. In 2016, San Diego used the eighth overall selection on Quantrill. He struggled a bit early in his career, but seems to have found his stride in Cleveland.

It took some time for him to settle in, but once July hit he found it. Since the beginning of July, each of Quantrill’s starts have gone at least five innings. He also had a streak of five starts where he didn’t allow more than one run in any appearance.

Since his first start in July, Quantrill is maintaining an ERA of 2.41 over nine starts that have totaled 52.1 innings. Over that time, he’s struck out 41 batters, equaling the amount of hits he’s allowed as well. There’s still a bit of a weakness in walks with 17, but that can be improved.

Quantrill’s best start undoubtedly came on Aug. 6 against Detroit when he tossed seven scoreless innings while striking out 10. While that might be his ceiling, and one Cleveland will happily take, his average start should work just fine for Cleveland moving forward into the 2022 season.

Triston McKenzie, SP, Cleveland Indians

The fifth spot of the rotation is where Cleveland could see a bit of competition, but at this point it seems like the edge should go to Triston McKenzie. The good news is that this competition would be between two capable starters, not between two struggling prospects just trying to fill a spot like we’ve seen this season.

More from Away Back Gone

• Cleveland Guardians tantalizingly close to locking up AL Central tiebreakers
• Cleveland Guardians: Terry Francona becomes meme in profanity-laced ejection
• Say goodbye to defensive shifts and hello to bigger bases, pitch clock in 2023
• Cleveland Guardians: Shane Bieber second-fastest to 800 strikeouts in major-league history
• The next week will make or break the Cleveland Guardians’ season

The edge for McKenzie really comes down to his potential, which was on full display in his last start. A first round pick by Cleveland in the 2015 MLB Draft, McKenzie was once one of the top prospects in the organization and is still just barely 24-years old after celebrating a birthday earlier this month.

Something about getting older must have helped McKenzie because since his birthday, each start has been progressively better. On Aug. 5 he gave up just three runs over seven innings against a tough Toronto offense. Then on Aug. 10 he improved to two runs over six innings against another difficult team in Oakland. However, his last start was by far the best of his career.

Going a full eight innings, McKenzie carried a perfect game into the eighth inning before being broken up by a Harold Castro single. When he left the inning, McKenzie had posted 10 strikeouts over eight innings while giving up just that one hit and no walks.

That start against Detroit is the potential that McKenzie has and it wasn’t necessarily a fluke. He’s had similar outings earlier this season they just weren’t perfect game bids. If he can find consistency in his starts, which should come with time, he should easily slot in as part of this rotation.