Cleveland Indians Report Card: Grading the first half of the season

Starting Pitching

How on Earth is someone supposed to judge Cleveland’s starting pitching the first half of this season? Seriously, I need someone to tell me. On one hand, the 2016 MLB Draft class trio of Shane Bieber, Aaron Civale and Zach Plesac have been as-advertised when healthy, if not exceeding expectations in the case of Civale. On the other hand, the six starters not named Bieber, Civale and Plesac have, well, tried.When Aaron Civale went down with a pitching hand injury in late June he was the MLB leader in wins with 10. The 2016 MLB Draft class trio combined for a 21-9 record in 39 starts this season, with a combined ERA of 3.50, a WHIP of 1.12 and 244 strikeouts over 247 innings. That is winning production and largely what has become expected of Indians pitching in the last decade and more.

Six other Tribe pitchers have notched a start this season if you exclude a Phil Maton lead bullpen day. Those other six starters include early season bullpen hand Cal Quantrill, opening day rotation members Triston McKenzie and Logan Allen, and prospects J.C. Mejia, Sam Hentges and Eli Morgan. Many of these six have shown flashes at one point or another, but haven’t quite put it all together for the Indians in 2021.

These other six pitchers to start this season have amassed a record of 3-18, a combined ERA of 7.70, a WHIP of 1.65 and 153 strikeouts in 41 starts, eating just 153.2 innings pitched. How can I put this as nicely as possible? Well, it’s like comparing apples and avocados. Two more combined starts than Bieber, Civale and Plesac, yet just half of their production has been an incredible strain on the bullpen and is far from sustainable.

In the defense of Morgan, Mejia and Hentges, they are playing on a very accelerated timetable from what should have been reasonably expected in 2021, but this level of performance is harrowing. To even consider grading the starting pitching feels like a sucker punch, but we have to meet somewhere in the middle considering the chasm that exists between the established starters and The Replacements. All things considered, the disparity couldn’t be much worse, so there’s nowhere to go but up, which helps justify giving the group a C-.

James Karinchak #99 of the Cleveland Indians (Photo by David Berding/Getty Images)

The Bullpen

Wait a minute, is that the ghost of Bryan Shaw coming out of the bullpen? The revival of Shaw’s career after three awful seasons between Colorado and Seattle has been fairly characteristic of the Tribe’s bullpen contributions. Though the baseball gods demand a sacrifice for the return of Shaw, as the three batter minimum rule has claimed the career of Oliver Perez early in 2021.

Nick Sandlin has also been a pleasant surprise in his age 24 season to go along with Phil Maton and Nick Wittgren. Those four arms have combined for an ERA of 3.91 and a WHIP of 1.21 in 119 innings, proving to be good enough to give the offense a chance to work its late inning magic. The major concern for the bullpen has been an inflated workload since the injuries to Bieber, Civale and Plesac, while every other starter for the Tribe has eclipsed six innings pitched just once in 41 starts.

Cal Quantrill also proved significantly more useful out of the bullpen before the need to stretch him out into a starter, registering a 1.17 ERA and a 1.26 WHIP in 23.1 innings pitched in relief. Even more recently the Indians have received a boost from journeyman Blake Parker since debuting June 5th, logging a 3.18 ERA across 13 appearances.

Closer deserves to be talked about independently of the rest of the bullpen, and the Tribe have two of them that turn almost every other franchise in baseball green with envy. James Karinchak has continued to embrace the “Wild Thing” persona through 38 appearances in the first half, owning an ERA of 2.49 and his patented ludicrous 15.4 K/9. Karinchak has gone 4-2 this season while adding nine saves to the mix.

Emmanuel Clase, the primary return to Cleveland in the Corey Kluber trade, has stymied opposing bats for much of the season and may find himself towards the top of rookie of the year conversation. He features a Cutter and a 4-Seam Fastball that both average 100MPH, so it’s fairly easy to see how he accumulated an ERA of 1.02 over the first 81 games, reaching the midway point with a 3-3 record and 11 saves as the other half of Cleveland’s closer-by-committee approach.

Things should improve for the bullpen as players (hopefully) return after the All-Star break, either by reinforcing the offense or getting stud starting pitching back. All things considered, the unit has been the most consistent for the 2021 Cleveland Indians in the first half. It’s hardly even debatable. The relief corps earns a very respectable B+ for the first half of the season.

The Infield

Cleveland entered 2021 with serious questions at several spots in the infield. The platoons of Andres Gimenez and Amed Rosario at shortstop and the failed Yu Chang, Jake Bauers experiment at first base. Fortunately, the Tribe had re-signed 2020 Gold Glove winner Cesar Hernandez, Jose Ramirez is still Jose Ramirez and Roberto Perez was still behind the dish.

However, the organization was reminded just how valuable Perez is, having played just 20 games in the first half of the season and unable to work with the young cast of pitchers thrust into the rotation. Austin Hedges, Ryan Lavarnway and Rene Rivera combined for the other 61 games in Perez’s absence, leaving an offensive black hole at the position. Perez did return in game 81, so barring any other injuries some extended time back in the lineup should be fruitful in every phase of the game.

Bobby Bradley made his much anticipated season debut on June 5th and took over every day first baseman duties after the injury to Josh Naylor, slashing .235/.316/.565 in 25 games with eight home runs and 17 runs driven in, doubling the production of Jake Bauers and Yu Chang in half the time. Amed Rosario has also made some noise over the past two months despite a slow April, fitting perfectly into the number two hole in the lineup behind Hernandez, slashing .264/.315/.375 in 74 games.

Jose Ramirez has been more vital to the Tribe’s success than ever, slashing .265/.345/.537 in the first half with 18 home runs, 18 doubles and 50 runs driven in while the team took until June to find a lineup that clicked. Recently selected to his third All-Star game, the 2020 AL MVP runner-up should be even more impactful with the hopeful return of Cleveland’s other stars in the second half.

Personally, I’ve always believed in grading on a curve. It’s entirely possible some college classes in my past would need to be re-taken to avoid a pass/fail (sorry Mom.) In that spirit, what the Indians have figured out since the beginning of June represents a formula for success for the next 81 games, at least in terms of offensive production from the infield, though the team could use some extra defensive drills on off days. The infielders have done enough to establish recency bias, granting a respectable B-.

The Outfield

We’re all acutely aware that the outfield has been a point of serious contention among fans and critics alike since allowing Michael Brantley to walk after the 2017 season. A rotating cast of prospects like Oscar Mercado (2019 excluded) and Bradley Zimmer blended with veterans the team took a flier on like Carlos Gonzalez and Domingo Santana have been less than ideal. Though based on the first 81 games of 2021, this write as one question; why the hell did the Miami Marlins let go of Harold Ramirez?

Cleveland claimed the other Ramirez off waivers in February, making his Indians debut May 3rd and has been an every day player for Terry Francona since, slashing .280/.326/.470 in 52 games. He has been a breath of fresh air for the team, both offensively and defensively, capable of playing any outfield position as needed and hitting both right and left-handed pitching very well (.274 and .284 batting averages respectively.) Ramirez is just 26, under team control until 2026, and seems like he’s carving out a home here with the Indians. You should expect more of the same the next 81 games and beyond.

More from Away Back Gone

• Cleveland Guardians tantalizingly close to locking up AL Central tiebreakers
• Cleveland Guardians: Terry Francona becomes meme in profanity-laced ejection
• Say goodbye to defensive shifts and hello to bigger bases, pitch clock in 2023
• Cleveland Guardians: Shane Bieber second-fastest to 800 strikeouts in major-league history
• The next week will make or break the Cleveland Guardians’ season

Speaking of outfielders that were surprisingly let go, this year’s veteran acquisition on a one-year deal is division foe-turned-friend Eddie Rosario, who victimized Cleveland for six seasons with Minnesota. Rosario has lacked some of the pop in his bat that Cleveland hoped would come with him, slashing .255/.297/.390 through 77 games with just seven home runs, but 46 RBIs. Rosario is a career .288 hitter at Progressive Field, which makes his .209 batting average at home this season, and just two of those seven home runs all the more bizarre compared to hitting .301 on the road.

Although primarily filling Cleveland’s DH spot in the lineup Franmil Reyes falls under the outfielder jurisdiction, playing right field in inter-league contests or worst-case scenarios. Reyes contributes next to nothing defensively, so let’s talk about his .261/.317/.562 slash line in 42 first half games for Cleveland, smacking 12 home runs and driving in 29. Reyes missed much of the first half with an oblique strain, but his pre-injury production should provide a huge boost to the lineup going forward.

The rest of the outfield, with the exception of Josh Naylor who was really turning a corner before a collision with Ernie Clement ended his season, has been abysmal to say the least. Ben Gamel lasted just 11 games, Oscar Mercado hasn’t had enough time to prove he can regain his 2019 form, Jordan Luplow still can’t hit a right-handed pitcher when healthy, and Bradley Zimmer has been exceptionally inept so far. Meanwhile, right down I-71, Tyler Naquin is experiencing a full on career revival with Cincinnati, further complicating public opinion of the front office.

With Naylor out for the rest of 2021, the Tribe have just two legitimate every day outfielders in Harold Ramirez and Eddie Rosario, saying that Rosario will be back from the injured list soon. Just like the infield, a curve is necessary to properly assess the outfield, but in this case the rotating cast outfielders Cleveland has deployed as needed unfortunately brings down the rest of the class, resulting in a C-.

The Bench and Utility

Alright, let’s not beat around the bush, the bench has been fairly disastrous, but that isn’t entirely the fault of the players. Cleveland didn’t sign a veteran utility player coming into 2021, opting instead to dip into the pool of flexible infielders in Triple-A Columbus and give Yu Chang the first opportunity to fill the role. Chang lasted 49 games, slashing .176/.211/.287 this season before being optioned back to Columbus in order to make room for Franmil Reyes returning from injury.

Owen Miller and Ernie Clement are the other two prospects given the chance to be Cleveland’s swiss-army man. Miller got the call next after slashing a scorching .406/.457/.609 in Columbus, but lasted just 17 games in the majors, slashing .106/.143/.128. Miller is just 24, rushed to the majors way too soon, so the concern is minimal in the long-term.

Clement currently holds the utility role for the Tribe, fairing a bit better with a slash line .216/.275/.243 in 13 games. The sample size is incredibly small, but his numbers are the best of the three who had a chance in the first half of the season. It’s unfair to judge Miller and Clement too harshly, but we’ve had parts of three seasons with Chang and the writing is on the wall, but the Indians will need more depth and production for the next 81, so the bench earns an F.

All in all, the Indians are one of the biggest surprises of the first half, earning a composite grade of a C overall. Hampered by injuries to almost every significant contributor on the roster in the first half of the season, this team still managed to spend time 10 games over .500 and finish their first 81 at 42-39. The team is skidding of late, but the offense gained genuine momentum in June approaching the midway point. With any semblance of luck in the second half, the Tribe may get their other stars back in the lineup in time to make a serious push in the next 81.