Cleveland Indians top 4 needs in the 2021 MLB Draft

Cleveland Indians 2021 MLB Draft Need #1: First Base

Since arriving in Cleveland, Bobby Bradley has been rather strong so far this year. It’s a small sample size with just three games, but one home run and two doubles is still promising. The downside is that the 25-year old prospect is the only first baseman on the Tribe’s Top 30 prospect list, being No. 18, and his prospect status will soon run out if he stays in Cleveland.

When it comes to building for the future, you don’t exactly want to be without a position on the Top 30 list. Bradley is young and has shown promise, but the next man up should always be on the radar. After Bradley, that’s not exactly the case. Once he is taken off the list, who’s the next first baseman to watch in the minors?

Drafting first basemen in the first round hasn’t exactly been a strength for the club in the past. Bradley was a third round selection, so you have to go back to the 2007 MLB Draft for the last first round first baseman by the Tribe. That was Beau Mills with the No. 13 pick. Mills played 74 games in Triple-A Columbus, but never made it to the majors.

That shouldn’t necessarily derail Cleveland from taking a first baseman since it was so long ago, but it shows how long it’s been since the team invested a high pick in the position. With that being said, the team shouldn’t reach either.

On the Top 200 prospects list for the 2021 MLB Draft, the first first baseman on the list isn’t until No. 70. Odds are, the Tribe could wait until the second round or later to address that need.

Cleveland Indians 2021 MLB Draft Need #2: Left-handed pitching

Over the last five seasons or so a left-handed starting pitcher on the Cleveland Indians was unheard of. This year, the club has attempted to add one to the rotation, first with Logan Allen and now with Sam Hentges. However, both of them are now off the Top 30 prospects list leaving just three left-handed pitchers on the list and none ranked higher than No. 22.

More from Away Back Gone

• Cleveland Guardians tantalizingly close to locking up AL Central tiebreakers
• Cleveland Guardians: Terry Francona becomes meme in profanity-laced ejection
• Say goodbye to defensive shifts and hello to bigger bases, pitch clock in 2023
• Cleveland Guardians: Shane Bieber second-fastest to 800 strikeouts in major-league history
• The next week will make or break the Cleveland Guardians’ season

Now, Cleveland has plenty of pitchers. Four of the club’s last five first round picks have been pitchers, but they’ve all been right-handed. That now reflects on the Top 30 list with seven of the 10 pitchers being right-handed. Perhaps the front office doesn’t care as much about right-handed versus left-handed pitchers, but there still seems to be a need for more balance.

Luckily, there’s a decent selection of left-handed pitchers in this draft class. The Top 200 list has five lefties in the Top 40, four of which are exiting high school at just 18-years old.

Given what the Tribe have in the minor leagues, a left-handed pitcher need is really just based off the organization’s philosophy. If pitchers are pitchers, then there are plenty within the club. However, if they value right-handed versus left-handed, then this need moves up the list.

Cleveland Indians 2021 MLB Draft Need #3: Catcher

Since 1965 the Cleveland Indians have drafted a total of four catchers in the first round. However, three of them came from 1977 or before, leaving just one since 1978. That one is Bo Naylor who the club took with the 29th pick in the 2018 MLB Draft. Naylor is currently the No. 3 prospect within the organization, so adding another might be a good move.

While Naylor is the only recent first round catcher by the Tribe, he isn’t the only one of the top prospect list. Bryan Lavastida is also on the list at No. 26, but given how quickly catchers can move up and also how quickly they can also get injured, having more wouldn’t be an awful idea.

The 2021 MLB Draft could also have a lot of catcher talent to pick from. There are four catchers in the draft’s top 25 prospects alone. It obviously remains to be seen if one of them could fall to the Tribe, but if that happens the team should at least consider it.

With both Roberto Perez and Austin Hedges coming close to the end of their deals there could be a changing of the guard behind the plate in the next few years, so having multiple options would help.

Cleveland Indians 2021 MLB Draft Need #4: Outfield

While the outfield in Cleveland has found some answers of late, the front office will want to be better prepared for the next wave than they were for this one. From 2012 to 2014 the club used four of their five first round selections on outfielders. The only problem was that they didn’t live up to expectations.

The first taken was Tyler Naquin in 2012 and of the group he probably played the best for the Tribe. Then came Clint Frazier in 2013, who would be traded for Andrew Miller. Cleveland then took two outfielders in the first round in 2014, being Bradley Zimmer, who is still trying to catch on, and Mike Papi who is playing in the Independent League.

Outfielders take a while to develop, or at least the ones that the Tribe have taken in the past have. If the front office wants to get ahead, they need to start taking outfielders now to allow ample time for them to get progress. Having a pair of 19-year old prospects in Isaiah Greene and Petey Halpin have already started the process, but this class could be deep at the position.

On the Top 200 list, there are seven outfielders in the top 30 alone, meaning if the Cleveland Indians want to continue building up their outfield of the future, the first round of the 2021 MLB Draft might be the perfect place to do it.