4. Trevor Bauer
The wild card of the rotation, in more ways than one.
Trevor Bauer is overflowing with potential, but inconsistency is holding him back from being a top-flight starter for this Indians staff.
He’s also a little wacky off the field. Case in point: him being forced to miss a start in the ALCS due to a drone accident that badly cut a finger on his pitching hand.
Bauer is full of surprises. Hopefully, the biggest surprise he brings is consistency that allows him to take a big step forward in his age-26 season.
Related: Indians opening the season with a healthy starting rotation
That said, he is not having a good spring. It’s hard to put a lot into performance in March, but he has given up five home runs. It’s easy to look past the 4.74 ERA on its own, but the home run number is very high. The Indians hope that won’t continue when the regular season begins next week.
Bauer also had a rough postseason, so expectations are lower for him than they are for Carrasco and Salazar. If those two guys perform, then the weight is lifted off Bauer’s shoulders. If they don’t, the pressure could fall squarely on Bauer.