Cleveland Indians 2015 Rule 5 Draft and Roster Decisions

Predicting the Tribe’s Roster Moves Before the 2015 Rule 5 Draft

As typical for this time of the year, some key roster decisions need to be made in anticipation of the MLB Rule 5 Draft.  This year the Cleveland Indians have an intriguing list of eligible players that may need to be rostered or risk losing them.  Very rarely have the Indians lost a player that wasn’t returned, though it has happened a few times with current Chicago Cubs closer Hector Rondon being one of the biggest losses.

The Cleveland Indians 40-man roster is currently at 36 players though that number could go down before final decisions are made.  Last year we saw the Indians add five players, most notably Giovanny Urshela and Cody Anderson, who both played a big part with the big league club in 2015.  So without further ado, here’s a look at some of the players that could be rostered by the Cleveland Indians.

The Near Certainties

Tyler Naquin – OF (34 games, 1 HR, 10 RBI, .348/.419/.468, 158 wRC+ at AA; 50 games, 6 HR, 17 RBI, .263/.353/.430, 127 wRC+ at AAA)

Naquin is a former first round pick by the Cleveland Indians out of Texas A&M. Drafted 15^th overall back in 2012, Naquin was seen as a polished college hitter with a plus arm and solid defense in the outfield. Since being drafted all Naquin has done is hit as he has a career batting average of .287 in his four minor league seasons and a very healthy .360 OBP.  He hasn’t displayed a ton of power but did hit seven home runs in just 84 combined games this year. 

More from Away Back Gone

• Cleveland Guardians: Terry Francona becomes meme in profanity-laced ejection
• Say goodbye to defensive shifts and hello to bigger bases, pitch clock in 2023
• Cleveland Guardians: Shane Bieber second-fastest to 800 strikeouts in major-league history
• The next week will make or break the Cleveland Guardians’ season
• The Cleveland Guardians offense is suddenly inept

Naquin’s biggest problem has been health.  In 2014, he looked primed for a call up to Triple-A Columbus before when his season was cut short after breaking his right hand after being hit by a pitch. The injury required surgery and instead of opening 2015 in Columbus, he opened with Double-A Akron. However, he made quick work of the Eastern League and was up in Columbus before Memorial Day. But as luck would have it, more injuries happened including a bad concussion when he collided with the outfield wall in July.

Before the injury it looked like Naquin would have a shot at a September call up to the big league club. His bat and outfield defense, which has been a pleasant surprise in centerfield, could have been a boost to the Cleveland Indians down the stretch.  Nevertheless, he’s at least shown enough to warrant a roster spot. He should open 2016 in Columbus but with the injury to Michael Brantley could see himself in Cleveland in short order.

Prediction: Rostered

* * * * *

Michael Clevinger – RHSP (9-8, 27 games, 26 starts, 158.0 IP, 2.73 ERA, 3.02 FIP at AA)

Clevinger was acquired from the Los Angeles Angels in 2014 for former fan favorite reliever Vinnie Pestano. At the time it seemed like the Indians simply wanted to dump Pestano and Clevinger would just be minor league depth/roster fodder as he posted a 4.79 ERA and 4.73 FIP after being acquired (and wasn’t too good prior to deal either). However, 2015 was a completely different story for Clevinger.

While Clevinger spent all of the regular season with Double-A Akron in 2015, he received a call up to Triple-A Columbus to help their playoff rotation…and help he did. In two starts in the International League playoffs Clevinger threw 15.1 innings without allowing a run. He only allowed five hits, walked just three while striking out an eye-popping 17!  After watching Cody Anderson get rostered last winter and ending up in Cleveland mid-season, one should not discount the same with Clevinger. Could show up on some top ten prospect lists for the Indians.

Prediction: Rostered

Next: The Good Bets

Credit: Scott Rovak-USA TODAY Sports

On the Fence

James Ramsey – OF (126 games, 12 HR, 42 RBI, .243/.327/.382, 107 wRC+ at AAA)

Had Ramsey been Rule 5 draft eligible last winter he’d have been a lock to have been added to the 40-man roster. He’s a former first round pick by the Cardinals (taken a few picks after Tyler Naquin) and was acquired by the Tribe for Justin Masterson at the deadline last summer. He had proven to be an on-base machine, posting a .369 on-base percentage in three seasons (including a stint in the Arizona Fall League). His OPS was also over .800 and he can play all three outfield positions.

However, 2015 was less than kind to James Ramsey. He struggled a bit with injury but even when healthy struggled at the plate. While he still posted a very healthy walk rate (10.5%), the rest of his game really suffered. His power was down as his .139 ISO was the worst since 2012 when he was fresh out of college, and his OBP was a career worst .327.  Given his struggles (most noticeably the lack of power), there’s a chance the Indians could leave him unprotected with thought he either won’t get picked or won’t stick with a club even if taken.

I personally think that’s a pretty big gamble though. He can still play all three outfield positions (and reasonably well) and could be a fourth or fifth outfielder on some teams, especially one looking to rebuild (like say, the Reds or Brewers). Given the openings on the 40-man and some of the guys still on it, I don’t think there’s much harm in rostering Ramsey.

Prediction: Rostered

* * * * *

Shawn Morimando – LHSP (10-12, 28 starts, 158.2 IP, 3.18 ERA, 3.64 FIP at AA)

Morimando threw a career high 158.2 innings for the Double-A Akron Rubberducks this year, seventh most in the Eastern League.  Overall his numbers have been very solid for the Tribe, though very little jumps out at you. He’s not a big strikeout guy, though he did raise his K-rate to a career best 7.26 per nine innings this year.  Walk rate and WHIP are pretty average.  Nothing about him screams “must add” as he is also undersized at just 5’11”.  However, he is a lefty and pitched well enough that a team could take a chance on him as a bullpen arm. Tribe saw this with the Orioles grabbing T.J. McFarland several years ago. There’s definitely some risk in leaving Morimando unprotected, and he’s one of the toughest choices for me personally…

Prediction: Not Rostered

* * * * *

Will Roberts – RHSP (6-2, 14 starts, 86.0 IP, 3.77 ERA, 4.00 FIP at AA; 3-4, 12 starts, 70.2 IP, 3.06 ERA, 4.26 FIP at AAA)

Roberts was on this list last year as well. He’s not flashy at all but a steady starting pitcher that also can work out of the bullpen.  He has limited upside as a starter but enough pitchability to potentially be a back-of-the-rotation starter or swing man in the bullpen.  He doesn’t strike many out (sub-5 per nine innings this season), but he also doesn’t allow many free passes (less than 1.5 walks per nine innings).  Overall though just too many better options to be rostered and enough depth in the system to leave him off the roster, again.

Prediction: Not Rostered

Next: The Longshots

Credit: Jennifer Buchanan-USA TODAY Sports

The Longshots

Todd Hankins – UT, Jeremy Lucas – C, Jake Lowery – C, Grant Sides – RHRP, LeVon Washington – OF, Dorssys Paulino – OF, Perci Garner – RHRP,  Ronny Rodriguez – UT

I try not to say something is “impossible” when it comes to roster decisions, but I would be very surprised if any of these players were added to the Tribe’s 40-man roster.  Hankins may have the best shot of the group as he’s able to play both the infield and outfield and is also currently playing in the Arizona Fall League. However, his bat is well below average and doesn’t have much power.  Lucas and Lowery are a pair of catchers that, while pretty solid are just too far from the big leagues (in my opinion) to seriously considering using a roster spot at this time.  Grant Sides made this list last year and while he still has some upside as seen by his 11.1 strikeout per nine in High-A this year, just not enough there to warrant as a reliever. Washington and Paulino are a pair of former high prospects with big tools that have just not panned out to this point. If a team thinks either can stick in the big leagues all year in 2016, by all means have at them.

Prediction: None are Rostered

Next: Cleveland Indians Sign Shane Robinson and Moore to Minor League Deals

Conclusion

While the Indians have only four open roster spots, I see the Indians rostering five guys with a sixth a strong possibility.  There are still a couple guys on the current 40-man roster that can be let go, most notably Jerry Sands who could easily be resigned to a minor league deal like Michael Martinez and Adam Moore were.  Michael Choice, Jayson Aquino, C.C. Lee and Tony Wolters would appear to be four others that could be removed should the Tribe decide to roster more than five (or decide they just really like Sands).

For me this is a much stronger Rule 5 class than the Indians had a year ago. I realistically could see the Tribe lose a guy or two this year. Whether those players stick or return I don’t know, but an intriguing mix of bullpens arms and athletic outfielders that could make the Tribe’s final decisions tough.

So who do you think the Cleveland Indians should add before the Rule 5 Draft? Did I miss someone?  What players (if any) do you think should be removed?  Let us know in the comments section below.